HYTA in Michigan: Can a Young Adult Keep a Criminal Charge Off Their Record?

Parents call our office asking the same question in different words: is there any way this doesn't follow my kid for the rest of his life? Usually the person charged is nineteen or twenty-two, has never been in trouble, and has just learned that a felony conviction is permanent. Michigan has a statute for that — the Holmes Youthful Trainee Act. It is narrower than most people expect.

Who HYTA Covers in Michigan

HYTA, MCL 762.11 to 762.15, lets a judge take a guilty plea and resolve the case without entering a judgment of conviction. Since October 1, 2021, it reaches an offense committed on or after the person's eighteenth birthday but before the twenty-sixth birthday. MCL 762.11(2). It runs through a guilty plea, so you cannot go to trial, lose, and then ask for it, and the defendant must consent — a court cannot impose it.

The age matters twice. If the offense happened on or after the twenty-first birthday, the same subsection says the person "must not be assigned to youthful trainee status without the consent of the prosecuting attorney." Under twenty-one you are asking a judge; twenty-one and over, the prosecutor comes first, and one who declines ends it.

The Charges HYTA Cannot Touch

Under MCL 762.11(3), HYTA does not apply to:

• a felony for which the maximum penalty is life imprisonment

• a major controlled substance offense

• a traffic offense

• criminal sexual conduct, first through fourth degree, under MCL 750.520b through 750.520e — including attempts and conspiracies — other than MCL 750.520d(1)(a) or 750.520e(1)(a), and assault with intent to commit it under MCL 750.520g

• 
  

The traffic exclusion catches people off guard. MCL 762.11(7)(b) defines a traffic offense as a felony or misdemeanor violation of the Michigan Vehicle Code — or of a substantially corresponding local ordinance — involving the operation of a vehicle. Drunk driving under MCL 257.625 is exactly that, and so is a city OWI ordinance.

MCL 762.11(4) adds three absolute bars; the court "shall not assign" the status if any applies. A prior conviction or juvenile adjudication for a listed offense requiring sex offender registration bars HYTA on any charge, not only a sex charge. If the current charge is a listed offense, the defendant must prove by clear and convincing evidence that he or she is not likely to commit another. And HYTA is barred if the court finds an aggravating factor from MCL 750.520b(1)(a)–(h), 750.520c(1)(a)–(l), 750.520d(1)(b)–(f), or 750.520e(1)(b)–(g).

The Judge Decides, and Nothing Requires a Yes

HYTA is discretionary, reviewed only for an abuse of discretion, and a trial court should weigh the seriousness of the offense "as a factor on an equal footing with the defendant's age." People v Khanani, 296 Mich App 175 (2012). Age opens the door; it does not carry a defendant through. In Khanani the Court of Appeals held the trial judge abused his discretion by granting the status on a first-degree home invasion, and reversed — a grant is not always the end of it.

What HYTA Looks Like, and How It Comes Undone

HYTA is not a dismissal handed over at the plea; it is supervision you have to finish. For an offense punishable by more than one year, MCL 762.13(1) allows up to three years of probation, up to a year in county jail, up to two years with the Department of Corrections, or custody followed by up to a year of probation. For an offense punishable by one year or less, MCL 762.13(3) requires probation of up to two years.

Finish it and the court "shall discharge the individual and dismiss the proceedings." MCL 762.14(1). Fall short and the status comes off. A judge may revoke any time before final release, MCL 762.12(1), and must revoke on a guilty plea or conviction during that period for certain offenses, including a life-maximum felony, a major controlled substance offense, or a firearm offense. MCL 762.12(2). The court can then enter an adjudication of guilt and sentence, with credit for time served in a Department of Corrections facility or county jail — not for time on probation. MCL 762.12(3).

"Not a Conviction" Is Not the Same as "Never Happened"

MCL 762.14(2) is the promise people remember: a HYTA assignment "is not a conviction for a crime" and, "except as provided in subsection (3)," the person "shall not suffer a civil disability or loss of right or privilege following his or her release from that status." Two limits are built into that sentence: the protection runs from release, not from the plea, and subsection (3) carves out an exception.

The record is closed, not erased. MCL 762.14(4) closes the proceedings to public inspection but keeps them open, for use only in their duties, to Michigan courts, the Department of Corrections, law enforcement, prosecutors, and the agency the statute still names the "family independence agency" (now the Department of Health and Human Services).

It still counts if there is a next time. A HYTA assignment is counted as a prior conviction when prior record variables are scored under the sentencing guidelines. MCL 777.50(4)(a)(i).

Registration turns on the date of the assignment. Michigan's registry applies to a person "convicted" of a listed offense. MCL 28.723(1)(a). For that purpose, "convicted" includes a HYTA assignment only if it was made before October 1, 2004. MCL 28.722(a)(ii); MCL 762.14(3). A HYTA assignment entered today — including on MCL 750.520d(1)(a) or 750.520e(1)(a) — does not by itself create a registration duty, though the question returns if HYTA is revoked and a conviction entered.

Firearms: do not assume HYTA restores firearm rights. Michigan's disability under MCL 750.224f applies to "a person convicted of a felony," and MCL 762.14(2) says a youthful trainee is not convicted. Federal law is a separate question: 18 USC 922(g)(1) turns on a conviction for a crime punishable by more than one year, and 18 USC 921(a)(20) says what constitutes such a conviction "shall be determined in accordance with the law of the jurisdiction in which the proceedings were held" — language pointing to state law. But no controlling federal decision we know of holds that a HYTA assignment falls outside 922(g)(1), and federal law has not always honored Michigan's "not a conviction" label. Treat federal exposure as unsettled, and get advice before possessing a firearm.

Immigration: HYTA is not protection. The Sixth Circuit, which covers Michigan, has held a Michigan HYTA disposition is a "conviction" under 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(A): a guilty plea establishes guilt and the court imposes a penalty, even though adjudication is withheld. Uritsky v Gonzales, 399 F.3d 728 (6th Cir 2005). A non-citizen needs immigration counsel before the plea, not after.

What This Means for You

HYTA belongs in the conversation early — not because the statute sets a deadline, but because it works by letting the court accept a plea without entering a judgment of conviction, MCL 762.11(2). Check eligibility first: an excluded charge, a prior listed offense, or an aggravating factor under MCL 762.11(4) means the strategy has to be something else. If the offense happened at twenty-one or older, prosecutor consent comes before anything a judge can do. And if immigration status, firearm rights, or registration is in the picture, those need answers before the plea.

Talk to Someone About Your Situation

Scozzari Law, PLLC handles criminal defense in Kent County and elsewhere in Michigan. If you want to know whether HYTA is available in your case and what it would ask of you, call the office at (616) 226-4343 or email us at james.scozzari@scozzarilaw.com to arrange a consultation and we can go through the charge and the alternatives.

This article is general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Scozzari Law, PLLC. Michigan law changes, and how it applies depends entirely on the facts of your case. If you have a family law or criminal matter in Kent County or elsewhere in Michigan, talk to a lawyer about your specific situation.